A Tale of Two Drafts

The upcoming NFL and NBA Drafts are more similar than any we’ve seen in recent history.  In fact, they’re so similar, it’s eerie.

NBA Wheel of FortuneThis year, I’ll feel like I’m watching a Wheel of Fortune rerun except instead of the lucky housewife spinning for millions of dollars in fabulous prizes, she’ll be replaced by NFL and NBA GMs and the dollar amounts on the wheel will be replaced by the cut-out faces of future league prospects.

Both drafts, the NFL Draft on May 8 and the NBA Draft on June 26, are laden with talent yet feature no clear cut number one.  There are a number of players in both drafts that warrant consideration for the top pick.

I don’t recall that ever being the case.  More often than not, there is one player that stands above the rest in at least one of the drafts, if not both.  That’s not the case in either draft this year and it should make for some interesting jockeying come draft days.

Georgia v South CarolinaThe Houston Texans have this year’s top NFL pick by virtue of their 2-14 record last year.  Since the end of the football season, we’ve heard them linked to names like JaDeveon Clowney, Johnny Manziel, Blake Bortles, Teddy Bridgewater, Khalil Mack and a handful of others.  Not even the most seasoned draft expert knows which one of them will go first or second or even fifth for that matter.  Don’t let them tell you any differently.  NFL War Room lips are sealed and the Texans aren’t about to let anybody know who they’re taking, only that they’re interested in all of them to throw off everyone else in the league.  In fact, it might be safe to say that, only one week away from the draft, not even they know who they’re taking.

Quite similarly, the NBA has a ton of young draft-eligible talent, none that might change the course of a franchise but certainly a few that can make an immediate impact on an already-contending team and many that should have successful careers.  Due to the NBA’s lottery draft, we don’t know who will have the first pick but we know some of the names they’ll be salivating over include Marcus Smart, Joel Embiid, Andrew Wiggins, Jabari Parker, Julius Randle and Doug McDermott.  One can make a legitimate argument for each of them being taken number one.

nba-crystal-ball1Like their NFL counterparts, only a crystal ball can determine which of those players, or perhaps even one I haven’t mentioned, will have the most prosperous career.

Successful drafts make franchises; unsuccessful picks break them or at least prolong their misfortune.  Choose the wrong quarterback with an early selection and set yourself back for years.  Choose the wrong NBA prospect and suffer the same fate.

Back to the NFL, JaDeveon Clowney is the man most everyone thought would be the number one pick ever since he nearly decapitated Vincent Smith in the Outback Bowl over a year ago.  He has visited with the Falcons, Lions, Jaguars, Texans, Rams and basically anyone who’s considering drafting him, which is every team in the league.  Only a few will get that chance.

Johnny Manziel 40The Johnny Manziel Tour Bus has been just as active with trips to Houston, Cleveland, Tampa Bay, Jacksonville, Oakland, New England and elsewhere.  I’m surprised no airline has contacted these guys to do a commercial.  They must be living out of their suitcases.  They’re cashing in on some frequent flyer miles, that’s for sure.  Manziel could go first, he could go tenth and trust me when I tell you, Mel Kiper’s daily words of wisdom are no help.  Don’t let his never-ending string of mock drafts fool you.  He may watch more game film than anyone else on the planet but he’s getting about as much honest information out of NFL GMs as you or I.

The bottom line is this.  Some of these players will be booms, others will be busts.  What makes the draft such a crap shoot is that, unless you’re name is LeBron James or Andrew Luck, nobody knows for years down the road which is which.

They just spin the wheel and hope for the best.

8 thoughts on “A Tale of Two Drafts

  1. NFL draft Inside Information… The Texans are going to pick someone… It sounds like Atlanta has a huge crush on Clowney but will that translate into a trade with Houston? It certainly makes sense for the Texans because they aren’t going anywhere without a top QB and why not trade down and get more value? If you look at the trade value charts the number 1 pick is valued at 3000 while Atlanta’s number 6 pick is only 1600 while Atlanta’s second round pick drops clear down to 530! If I was Houston I’d cut the Falcons a break and offer them my number one pick for their 1st and 2nd round picks this year along with their 2nd round pick next year… Then with the 6th pick I’d take the player I was contemplating with the first pick anyway (At least one of the top 3 QBs will still be available…). Will Atlanta oblige? Clowney might be a HOF player but that doesn’t necessarily win the championship for your team. Quarterbacks make that their specialty…

  2. Yeah, but Dwin.

    Which quarterback is Houston willing to mortgage their future on?

    Bortles? Manziel? Bridgewater?

    That seems like more of a gamble, no?

    Can that franchise really afford to do that at this point?

    I’m not sure any of those guys are ready to step in immediately and get the job done. In fact, I’m pretty sure they aren’t.

    Wouldn’t it be wiser to take Clowney and try to find a more proven QB through free agency?

  3. Name a free agent QB that is capable of going all the way… If there is one then his past team really screwed up. Fully half of the teams in the NFL have a need at QB! Name a pass rusher who has won a Super Bowl…

    When I was an NFL General Manager… I built teams to last for years… I believe they’re called dynasties! The days of mortgaging the future seems to have been left to the federal government…

  4. Al…

    I’m not so sure I agree with you on this one, man.

    There’s plenty of drama going into this NFL Draft. We could see trades. We don’t know who’s going where. Or maybe we do and there’s just a lot of silly hoopla surrounding it.

    I say if the Texans take Clowney, it’ll be sort of anti-climactic, however, if they pick Manziel, I fully expect Radio City to go nuts.

    And don’t be surprised if the Bucks get screwed, pick fourth and take some European player who decides he doesn’t want to play there.

  5. Dwin…

    A) If I knew the answer to your first question, I’d be an NFL GM and a pretty successful one at that.

    B) Are you actually downgrading the importance of a threatening pass rush as if NFL champions weren’t centered around great defenses?

    Bears? Ravens? Bucs? Giants? C’mon, man.

  6. Not downgrading great defenses… I’m comparing which players are responsible for the most championships on a position basis… in over 40 Super Bowls QB’s have won over 25 MVP’s…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>